On any given day, you might see a customer message your support team, asking why their order hasn’t shipped. Meanwhile, a top-selling vendor accidentally lists the same product twice — once with outdated pricing. A few minutes later, a new seller uploads a product with a suspiciously perfect 5-star review. Sound familiar?

Marketplaces are busy, messy, complex ecosystems. From onboarding new sellers and managing catalog data to personalizing the buyer journey and preventing fraud, there are a lot of moving parts to manage. And it takes more than just good intentions to keep the system running.

Adobe reports that consumers are using generative AI to inform their purchases more often. Data shows that when using AI, shoppers stay on websites 8% longer, they browse 12% more pages on each site, and 92% say AI improves their shopping experience.

Without considering AI in your business strategy, you might be leaving money on the table. But successful adoption takes patience and planning. 

So how do marketplaces use AI? Read on to learn how AI works in the multi-vendor space, where it creates the most value, and what to avoid when adopting AI tools in your business.  

What is marketplace AI?

Marketplace AI refers to the use of artificial intelligence tools and models to improve how digital marketplaces operate — enhancing both the seller and buyer experience. Here are some of the most useful types of AI for multi-vendor platforms:

1. Generative AI

Generative AI creates new content from scratch, including text, images, and product copy. In marketplaces, it can write product descriptions, generate marketing images, and even help sellers ideate new offerings.

Poshmark recently integrated a generative AI tool called Smart List AI that scans product photos for details like product name, size, and color to help sellers create high-quality product listings 48% faster. Poshmark’s visual search tool, Posh Lens, also uses generative AI by matching user-uploaded photos to listings on the shop.

2. Natural Language Processing (NLP)

NLP is the broad field of AI that focuses on helping machines understand, interpret, and generate human language. It's used to power things like: spelling and grammar correction, search engines, chatbots, voice assistants, sentiment analysis, and language translation.

Airbnb uses NLP to analyze written reviews and online forum messages to uncover user sentiment and remove bias from star ratings. This helps the company provide a more accurate picture of user experiences.

3. Large Language Models (LLMs)

LLMs like GPT-4 are a newer, more advanced type of NLP tool. They are trained on huge datasets and can handle more complex, open-ended tasks, such as: writing product descriptions, generating personalized content, answering nuanced questions, and summarizing long documents.

LLMs drive Amazon’s top-of-the-page summaries, which condense thousands of reviews into a few key takeaways on product pages. These help shoppers make better-informed purchases, faster. 

4. Anomaly Detection

Anomaly detection involves using AI to detect unusual patterns that might denote fraudulent transactions.

For example, Uber uses AI-powered anomaly detection to monitor activity on its platform to protect both drivers and riders. Machine learning models help detect events like payment fraud, account takeover, and GPS spoofing and flag them for human review.

How do marketplaces use AI?

There are plenty of creative ways to use AI for everyday marketplace tasks — from improving user experience to streamlining back-end operations. Here are a few areas where AI can make a major difference in how you run your marketplace.

AI for catalog data clean-up

Inconsistent labeling or missing information can lead to buyer frustration, mistrust, abandoned carts, and lost revenue. With the help of AI, vendors can reduce the manual effort required for product management and ensure all listings are created equally.

• Generate product titles and descriptions: Free tools like ChatGPT can help sellers write clean, compelling listings that appeal to buyers.

• Data normalization: If your sellers upload inconsistent data (e.g., "red," "crimson," and "burgundy") as separate entries, AI can standardize terms for more consistency and better searchability — ensuring buyers can find what they’re looking for.

AI to improve the buyer journey

Shoppers are more likely to click the “buy now” button when they find exactly what they want (and sometimes, even what they didn’t know they wanted). By choosing the right AI tools, marketplace owners can significantly improve the buyer experience through personalization and improved search functionality.

Personalization

AI recommends products based on a user’s browsing history, preferences, and previous purchases. It can personalize the buyer experience by suggesting items frequently bought together, customizing homepage feeds, and tailoring marketing emails to specific audience segments.

Etsy has embraced an AI marketplace approach. The marketplace combines human expertise in spotting high-quality, trending items with AI curation tools to inspire buyers and customize their shopping experience.

Airbnb, an early AI adopter, uses predictive search capabilities guided by machine learning to provide personalized travel recommendations. Results based on guests’ travel dates, preferences, and previous app usage improve the chance of successful reservations.

Search

AI transforms the marketplace search function from basic keyword matching into a smart, intent-aware tool that can provide much more relevant results. Here are some examples:

• Semantic search understands natural language queries like “sleevess summer dress for a wedding” or “blue thigh-length coat”
• NLP delivers more relevant matches by correcting misspellings and recognizing synonyms
• Visual and voice search options enhance accessibility for diverse users

ThredUp is using generative AI in its image search, style expert chats, and digital measurement tool to help consumers find exactly what they want and drive growth in the second-hand clothing market. 

AI to create custom supply

Some marketplaces are raising the bar for user experience by using AI to co-create unique products on demand. Instead of simply recommending existing items, these platforms allow customers to actively shape what they buy — whether it’s customizing a design, choosing features, or generating entirely new product concepts.

Arcade, for example, is the first of its kind — a top innovator in AI marketplace creation. Its platform allows users to generate product ideas through text and image prompts, which AI turns into production-ready designs. Skilled artisans handcraft the custom items and ship them to the buyers. Arcade originated with jewelry creation and has since expanded to include rugs, ceramics, and textiles.

Arcade’s approach not only gives shoppers exactly what they want but also helps marketplaces reduce overproduction and stand out with one-of-a-kind offerings.

6 Common AI mistakes to avoid

While AI, like many of today’s retail trends, offers big advantages, jumping in without a clear strategy can lead to wasted time, lost sales, and missed opportunities. Many marketplace operators get caught up in the hype and rush implementation without thinking through long-term implications. To make AI work for your business, it’s important to be aware of common missteps. Here’s what to watch out for:

1. Investing too much, too quickly: AI is exciting, but jumping into expensive solutions without a proven product-market fit can backfire. Start small, validate your use cases, and scale once you see clear value.

2. Overcomplicating the stack: Just because you can build something doesn’t mean you should. Don’t add advanced AI features if simpler automation or clear UX design solves the problem.

3. Using AI without oversight: AI models can make mistakes, introduce bias, or create compliance issues. Always include human-in-the-loop reviews for sensitive tasks.

4. Not training your team to use AI effectively: Your team won’t automatically understand how to use AI tools effectively. Invest in training and change management to ensure smooth adoption.

5. Ignoring privacy and compliance: AI often involves data — and lots of it. Be sure you're complying with industry regulations when handling user data.

6. Not using AI at all: Some teams avoid AI entirely out of fear or inertia. This is a missed opportunity. Even small-scale adoption (e.g., AI chatbots, auto-tagging) can have a major impact.

Future-proof your marketplace with intentional AI adoption

AI is no longer a futuristic idea. Rather, it’s a practical, powerful tool that’s reshaping how marketplaces operate. From cleaning up messy product catalogs to personalizing the buyer experience and even generating unique, made-to-order inventory, AI can deliver real value at every stage of your platform’s growth.

The success of companies like Amazon, Airbnb, Poshmark, Etsy, and Arcade highlights what’s possible when AI is used intentionally. These brands are using AI not just to automate tasks, but to elevate the overall experience for buyers, sellers, and operators alike.

That said, effective AI marketplace integration isn’t about chasing the flashiest tools or trends. It’s about solving real problems. Start with simple, high-impact use cases. Stay focused on your customers and your team. And don’t lose sight of the human touch. AI should enhance your marketplace, not replace the people behind it.

With the right approach, and the right AI tools, marketplace leaders will gain a competitive edge with platforms that are more efficient, more personalized, and better equipped to scale.

Stay current with marketplace trends. Subscribe to the Nautical Commerce newsletter today.

‍